Christmas game prizes don’t need to be expensive. The best prizes are fun, useful, or just silly enough to make people laugh.
Whether you’re playing a classic Saran Wrap Ball, a fast-paced Minute to Win It, or a holiday Dice Game, the right prizes make everything more exciting.
Here are prize ideas for different Christmas games to inspire your holiday party.
More Christmas-inspired posts worth a look!
Fun Family Christmas Games For Quality Bonding Time!
1st December Box Ideas
Secret Santa Gifts
Christmas Eve Box Ideas For Kids
Please note that this article may contain affiliate links. You can read my full disclosure at the bottom of this page.
1. Saran Wrap Ball Game Prizes
The Saran Wrap Ball is all about surprise. Each layer hides something new, so it’s best to use a mix of cheap fillers and a few big surprises.
A smart twist: make two separate Saran Wrap Balls — one for kids and one for adults. That way, the prizes are age-appropriate and fun for everyone.
For Kids
Fillers:
- Mini toys (Lego blind bags, Hot wheels cars, Finger puppets)
- Stickers or temporary tattoos
- Play-Doh tubs or slime tubs
- Holiday pencils or erasers
- Hot Cocoa Packets
- Glow sticks or bouncy balls
- Mini Bubble Blowers
- Keychains (cartoon or holiday themed)
- Small puzzles or card games (Uno Mini, Go Fish)
- Candy (Skittles, M&M’s, Starburst, Twix, Nerds, Tootsie Rolls, Lifesavers, Hot Tamales)
- Plush keychains or mini stuffed animals
- Chocolate (Hershey’s minis, KitKat minis, Reese’s cups, Snickers)
- Seasonal prizes like snowman stress balls or reindeer antlers
Big Prizes:
- Fuzzy socks or mittens
- Mini coloring books with crayons
- Small plush toys
- Kid gift cards ($5 McDonald’s, ice cream shop)
- Glow-in-the-dark stars for their room
- Cash ($1s, $5s, $10s, $20s)
CHRISTMAS GAMES BUNDLE – INSTANT DOWNLOAD!
For Adults
Fillers:
- Candy bars (Reese’s, KitKat, Snickers, Twix, Hershey’s minis)
- Snack packs (Pringles minis, Goldfish crackers, trail mix, Oreo minis)
- Lip balm or Vaseline Lip Therapy
- Hand sanitizer or travel-size lotion
- Hand sanitizerHand sanitizer (travel size)
- Scrunchies or headbands
- Small tissue packs
- Mini Bath Bombs
- Makeup samples or skincare trial packs
- Mini Flashlights
- Post-it notes, pens, or mini notebooks
- Funny fillers (condiment packets, silly novelty trinkets)
Big Prizes:
- Gift cards (Target, Starbucks, Amazon, gas cards)
- Cash ($1s, $5s, $10s, $20s)
- Lottery scratch-offs
- Mini liquor bottles (Fireball, Baileys, Smirnoff)
- Small Bluetooth Speaker
- Christmas Ornament Set
- Gourmet chocolates (Lindt, Ghirardelli)
- Fuzzy socks or slippers
- Seasonal game tickets
(bowling passes, skating tickets, mini-golf passes, movie tickets) - Mini Portable Charger
- Holiday candles or small décor pieces
- Jewelry or Burt’s Bees gift sets
Tip: It usually takes about 3 large rolls of plastic wrap to make one good-sized ball.
2. Minute to Win It Game Prizes
Minute to Win It games are short and silly, so the prizes should be quick, fun, and easy to hand out.
Prize ideas:
- Scratch-off tickets (for extra excitement)
- Band-Aid packs (for kids)
- Car air freshener (for adults)
- Plastic yo-yos (for kids)
- Household tasks (like do the dishes for a week)
- Small coloring books with crayons (for kids)
- Mini hand warmers (for adults)
3. Gift Exchange Game Prizes
Gift exchange games are all about the surprise. These prizes work best when they’re wrapped so no one knows what’s inside.
Prize ideas:
- Cozy blankets or throws
- Holiday candles
- Funny gag gifts (toilet paper roll with a Christmas label, silly oven mitts, quirky mugs)
- Snack gift sets (popcorn tins, hot cocoa sampler, cookie tins)
- Coffee shop gift cards
- Family games (Uno, Exploding Kittens, Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza)
- Mini tool kits or phone chargers
- Cute holiday décor (snow globes, tabletop trees)
- Seasonal game tickets (bowling, skating, or movie passes)
If you’re planning a White Elephant exchange, check out my post on White Elephant Gift Ideas for even more inspiration.
SEE ALSO: Most Likely To Christmas Edition:
25 FUN CHRISTMAS GAMES PRINTABLES
4. Board Game Prizes
If you’re doing a family game night or holiday tournament, having prizes makes it extra fun.
Prize ideas:
- Candy bundles or “movie night kits” (popcorn, candy, soda)
- Mini trophies or medals
- Fuzzy slippers or socks
- Fast food gift cards ($5–$10)
- Winner’s crown or silly Christmas hat (to wear proudly)
- A new board game (Uno Flip, Jenga, Phase 10)
- Holiday dessert prize (peppermint bark, fudge, cookies)
SEE ALSO: Christmas favors for parties prizes
5. Dice Game Prizes
Christmas Dice Games (like the “Gift Grab Dice Game”) need lots of small, swappable prizes.
Create more family bonding time with these DIY Christmas gift ideas!
Prize ideas:
- Wrapped candy or chocolate bars
- Holiday ornaments
- Fuzzy socks or gloves
- Scrunchies or cozy headbands
- Mini lotions or lip balms
- $5 gift cards (coffee shops, gas cards, fast food)
- Small kitchen gadgets (measuring spoons, cookie cutters)
- Scratch-off lottery tickets
- Seasonal snacks (cocoa packs, holiday popcorn)
- Small plush toys or stress balls
6. Funny & Gag Prize Ideas
Sometimes the best part of Christmas games is the laughter. Adding a few funny prizes keeps things lighthearted.
Ideas for gag prizes:
SEE ALSO: Stocking Stuffers For Men
- A can of Spam wrapped like treasure
- Toilet paper with a bow on it
- Ugly Christmas socks
- Silly oven mitts
- “World’s Smallest” novelty toys
- Fake cash
- Random condiments (mustard or hot sauce packets)
These work especially well in White Elephant exchanges or Saran Wrap Ball games for adults.
See full list of White Elephant Gift Ideas.
Where to Buy Christmas Game Prizes
You don’t need to hunt too far. Most of these can be found at:
- Dollar Tree → perfect for fillers like candy, toys, stationery
- Target / Walmart → great for cozy items, mugs, blankets, and affordable gift cards
- Amazon → bulk packs of candy, toys, or themed prize bundles (and easy delivery)
- Local stores → movie tickets, arcade tokens, or skating passes
Prize Budgeting Tips
You don’t have to overspend. Here’s a simple guide:
- Saran Wrap Ball (10–12 players): $20–30 in fillers + $20–40 in big prizes
- Minute to Win It: $10–20 for candy and trinkets
- Gift Exchange: set a group budget ($10–$20 per gift is common)
- Board Games & Dice Games: $15–30 depending on group size
The key is to mix fillers with a few surprises so every game feels exciting.
Kid vs. Adult Prize Adaptations
Many of these games work for both kids and adults, but the prizes should change:
- For kids: stickers, toys, candy, coloring sets, puzzles, slime, Play-Doh, glow sticks
- For adults: cash, gift cards, lottery tickets, mini alcohol bottles, cozy socks, candles, skincare items
If you’re planning for both, keep them separate (two Saran Wrap Balls or clearly labeled prizes) so everyone gets something age-appropriate.
Final Tip
Mix and match! You don’t need to buy everything on these lists. Start with candy and fun fillers, then add in a few exciting prizes like gift cards, cash, or cozy holiday items.
And remember, if kids and adults are both playing, make two Saran Wrap Balls so everyone ends up with prizes they’ll enjoy.
Related Posts You’ll Love:
Stocking Stuffers for Women
Stocking Stuffers for Kids
Wrapping Up Game Prizes
And that’s the scoop – your family game nights are all set to become epic battles of victory.
So, the next time you strategize, roll, or make the perfect charade guess, remember that it’s not just about who wins the game.
It’s about seizing the titles of Snack Sultan, Remote Control Royalty, or Wordsmith Wizard – the ultimate game prize titles.
Get ready to claim your throne, revel in the laughter, and bask in the glory of being a family game champion.
Game on!
My Grandchildren put the ball together with prizes I buy. My “evil” lol, Granddaughter always separates the sock’s and just wraps one at a time! Unless you are lucky enough to get both of them you have to negotiate a trade. It adds to the fun.
That’s a smart idea! Thanks for sharing.